Academic drift of technical VET teacher education in Germany, Sweden, and other Nordic countries

Franz Kaiser

doi:10.3384/njvet.2242-458X.25151148

Authors

Franz Kaiser University of Rostock, Germany https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6569-2552

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3384/njvet.2242-458X.25151148

Keywords:

academisation, history, vocational teacher education, Germany, Sweden, Nordic countries

Abstract

The academisation of vocational education and training (VET) teacher pathways, often referred to as academic drift, is a relatively recent phenomenon in Europe, with significant implications for both teacher education and VET research. This article examines the historical development of VET teacher education in Germany and Sweden, using these countries as cases to explore how political decisions and academic models have influenced their education. The study highlights the resulting tensions between the demands of academic work and the practical competencies required of VET teachers. The emphasis is on the teachers in the technical VET domain, given the distinct developmental trajectories observed in disparate disciplines, such as commerce, agriculture, and others.

The research draws on document analysis, expert discussions, and workshops with VET teachers conducted during long-term research visits to Nordic countries, alongside findings from the Erasmus project ‘VETteach.’ After tracing the evolution of technical VET teacher education in Germany, the article explores the establishment of VET research as a discipline and its impact on teaching practices in the study programmes. It then shifts focus to Sweden, where the effects of academisation on VET research and teacher education are examined. A comparison with other Nordic countries provides additional context. The findings reveal that while academic drift has enhanced the theoretical underpinnings of VET, it has also created tensions between academic learning and vocational competencies, with significant implications for the future of VET teacher training and research in Europe.

References

Alam, S., Heikkinen, A., & Molzberger, G. (2023). Technologisation as the planetary solution for environmental care and social progress? Critical questions to vcational and adult education. In A. Heikkinen, & N. J. Jinia (Eds.), Environmental care and social progress: (Im)possible connection? (pp. 75–100). Osder.

Asghari, H., & Berglund, I. (2020). Svensk yrkeslärarutbildning efter reformen 2011: Lärarstudenters uppfattningar om antagning, VFU och läraranställning [Swedish vocational teacher education after the reform 2011: Teacher students’ perceptions of admission, practicum internship and teacher appointment]. Nordic Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 10(2), 21–43. https://doi.org/10.3384/njvet.2242-458X.2010221

Bauer, W. (2007). TVET teachers and instructors in Germany. In P. Grollmann, & F. Rauner. (2007). International perspectives on teachers and lecturers in technical and vocational education (pp. 123–158). Springer.

Brechmacher, R., & Gerds, P. (1993). Grundmodelle der Gewerbelehrerbildung im historischen Wandel [Basic models of vocational teacher training in historical change]. In A. Bannwitz, & F. Rauner (Eds.), Wissenschaft und Beruf: Berufliche Fachrichtungen im Studium von Berufspädagogen des gewerblich-technischen Bereiches [Science and profession: Branchspecifics in the curriculum of vocational teachers in the industrial-technical field] (pp. 38–60). Donat.

BIBB. (2010). 40 Jahre Bundesinstitut für Berufsbildung: 40 Jahre Forschen – Beraten – Zukunft gestalten [40 years of the Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training: 40 years of researching – advising – shaping the future]. BIBB.

Brüchner, M., Isik, B., & Riehle, T. (2024). Kompetenzorientierte Lehrer:innen-bildung für die berufliche Bildung der Fachrichtung Metalltechnik [Competence-based teacher training for vocational training in metal technology]. In M. Niethammer, M. Schweder, & M. Liebig (Eds.), Didaktiken der Beruflichen Fachrichtungen: Optimierung getrennt-gemeinsam denken [Didactics of the vocational disciplines: Thinking optimisation separately – together] (pp. 253–274). Wbv. https://doi.org/10.3278/9783763974375

Busemeyer, M., & Trampusch, C. (2012). The comparative political economy of collective skill formation. In M. Busemeyer, & C. Trampusch (Eds.), The political economy of collective skill formation (pp. 3–38). Oxford University Press.

Carnein, O., Damnik, G., Krause, G., & Vanier, D. (2023). Spezifische Aspekte von Trainings pädagogischer Kompetenzen in Abgrenzung zu anderen Lehr-Lern-Situationen in der Lehrkräftebildung (Tagungsband) [Specific aspects of training in pedagogical competences in contrast to other teaching-learning situations in teacher training (Conference documentation)]. University of Rostock RosDok. https://rosdok.uni-rostock.de/resolve/id/rosdok_document_0000023205

Cedefop (2016). Vocational education and training in Sweden (VET in Europe reports). https://cumulus.cedefop.europa.eu/files/vetelib/2016/2016_CR_SE.pdf

Clark, T. N. (1973). Prophets and patrons: The French university and the emergence of the social sciences. Harvard University Press.

Dir. 2008:41. Utbildning till yrkeslärare [Training of VET teachers]. https://www.regeringen.se/rattsligadokument/kommittedirektiv/2008/04/dir.-200841/

Eiríksdóttir, E. (2020). Program coherence and integration of school- and work-based learning in the Icelandic dual vocational education and training (VET) system. Education Science, 10(11), 314. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci10110314

Fahle, S., Faßhauer, U., Kaiser, F., & Krugmann, S. (2016). Buntes Bild trotz KMK-Vorgaben: Kooperative Studiengänge des Lehramts für berufliche Schulen [Colourful picture despite state requirements: Cooperative study programmes for the teaching profession at vocational schools]. In T. Bals, A. Diettrich, M. Eckert, & F. Kaiser (Eds.), Diversität im Zugang zum Lehramt an berufsbildenden Schulen: Vielfalt als Chance? [Diversity in access to the teaching profession at vocational schools: Diversity as an opportunity?] (pp. 67–92). Eusl.

Deißinger, T. (1998). Beruflichkeit als “organisierendes Prinzip“ der deutschen Berufsausbildung [Beruflichkeit as the ‘organising principle’ of German vocational training]. Eusl.

Götzl, M., Geiser, P., Jahn, R. W., & Frind, H. (2019). The academic institutionalisation of VET as a science in the German-speaking area: A collective biographical and network analytical study of discipline formation in the 20th century. In F. Marhuenda, & M. J. Chisvert-Tarazona (Eds.), Pedagogical concerns and market demands in VET (pp. 1–9). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.2641693

Gonon, P. (2020). Dilettantismus als Dispositiv: Zur disziplinären Entwicklung historischer Berufsbildungsforschung [Dilettantism as a dispositive: On the disciplinary development of historical vocational training research]. In F. Kaiser, & M. Götzl (Eds.), Historische Berufsbildungsforschung: Perspektiven auf Wissenschaftsgenese und -dynamik [Historical vocational training research: Perspectives on the genesis and dynamics of science] (pp. 32–48). Eusl.

Gonon, P., & Bonoli, E. (2023). Vocational education and training needs a middle range theory – an exploration: History, difficulties and ways of developing a theoretical approach to VET. In bwp@ Berufs- und Wirtschaftspädagogik – online, Spezial 19: Retrieving and recontextualising VET theory (pp. 1–20). https://www.bwpat.de/spezial19/gonon_bonoli_spezial19.pdf

Greinert, W.-D. (2004). Die europäischen Berufsausbildungssysteme: Über-legungen zum theoretischen Rahmen der Darstellung ihrer historischen Entwicklung [The European vocational training systems: Reflections on the theoretical framework of the account of their historical development]. Europäische Zeitschrift Berufsbildung, 32(2), 18–26.

Grollmann, P., & Rauner, F. (Eds.). (2007). International perspectives on teachers and lecturers in technical and vocational education. Springer.

Hägele, T., & Pangalos, J. (2012). Entwicklung der Gewerblich-Technischen Wissenschaften im Zeitraum von 1998 bis 2009 [Development of comercial- technical sciences in the period from 1998 to 2009]. In M. Becker, G. Spöttl, & T. Vollmer (Eds.), Lehrerbildung in Gewerblich-Technischen Fachrichtungen [Teacher education in comercial-technical branches] (pp. 65–96). wbv.

Hedman, A (2001). I nationens och det praktiska livets tjänst: Det svenska yrkesskolesystemets tillkomst och utveckling 1918 till 1940 [In the service of the nation and practical life: The development of the Swedish vocational school system from 1918 to 1940] [Doctoral dissertation, Umeå university]. http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:155640/FULLTEXT02.pdf

Helms Jørgensen, C., Olsen, O. J., & Persson Thunqvist, D. (Eds.). (2018). Vocational education in the Nordic countries: Learning from diversity. Routledge.

Hörner, W. (2004). „Europa“ als Herausforderung für die Vergleichende Erziehungswissenschaft: Reflexionen über die politische Funktion einer pädagogischen Disziplin [‘Europe’ as a challenge for comparative education: Reflections on the political function of a pedagogical discipline]. Tertium comparationis, 10(2), 230–244.

Hoppe, M., & Kaiser, F. (2021). Comparing VET teacher education at university level in five European countries. In C. Nägele, B.E. Stalder, & M. Weich (Eds.), Pathways in vocational education and training and lifelong learning: Proceedings of the 4th Crossing Boundaries Conference in Vocational Education and Training, Muttenz and Bern online, 8.–9. April (pp. 165–171). VETNET, University of Applied Sciences and Arts Northwestern Switzerland and Bern University of Teacher Education. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4636423

Kaiser, F., & Lindberg, V. (2019). Vocational teachers in the Swedish and Finnish vocational education systems. In F. Marhuenda, & M. José Chrisvert-Tarazona (Eds.), Pedagogical concerns and market demands in VET (pp. 301–307). Valencia University. https://zenodo.org/records/2641712

Kaiser, F. (2020). Reflections on typologies of comparison studies and the necessity of cultural-historical views illustrated by the analysis of the Swedish vocational education system from abroad. In M. Pilz, & J. Li (Eds.), Comparative vocational education research (pp. 259–274). Springer.

Kaiser, F. (2021). Academisation of the vocational school teaching profession and the genesis of vocational educational science: A historic country comparison of Sweden, Finland and Germany. Nagoya University Bulletin, (4), 1–25.

Kaiser, F. (2023). Schweden: Bd. 57. Internationales Handbuch der beruflichen Bildung [Sweden: Bd. 57. International handbook of vocational education]. Barbara Budrich. https://www.bibb.de/dienst/publikationen/de/download/18911

Kaiser, F. (2024). Let’s avoid tilting at windmills, or Why we are studying vocational education and training (VET) with more than just one theory. In bwp@ Berufs- und Wirtschaftspädagogik – online, Spezial 19: Retrieving and recontextualising VET theory (pp. 1–29). https://www.bwpat.de/spezial19/kaiser_en_spezial19.pdf

Kalisch, C., & Kaiser, F. (Eds.). (2019). Bildung beruflicher Lehrkräfte: Wege in die pädagogische Königsklasse [Vocational teacher training: Paths to the pedagogical royal class]. wbv.

Lagström, A. (2012). Lärlingslärare: En studie av hur hur vård- och yrkeslärare uppdrag formas i samband med införandet av gymnasial lärlingsutbildning [The apprenticeship programme teacher: A study of how the role of the vocational teacher is formulated in conjunction with the introduction of upper secondary school apprenticeships] [Doctoral dissertation, Göteborg Universitet]. http://hdl.handle.net/2077/27999

Lensjø, M. (2024). Vocational teachers’ craft knowledge and working‑life experiences in building and construction: A narrative study of embodied and tacit learning. Vocations and Learning, 17, 333–350. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12186-024-09344-3

Lindberg, V. (2004). Swedish vocational education and research in an international context. Skolverket.

Lindberg, V. (2014). Vocational knowing and the content in vocational education. International Journal of Training research, 1(2), 40–61.

Lindberg, V., Klope, E., Andersson, I., Chrstidis, M., Berg-Christoffersson, G., & Tyson, R. (2014, 9. April). Two Swedish PhD-programmes in vocational pedagogy: Background, aims and strategies. [Conference presentation]. ECER, Porto, Portugal. https://eera-ecer.de/ecer-programmes/conference/19/contribution/32749/

Lipsmeier, A. (2010). Genese der berufspädagogischen Forschung [Genesis of vocational education research]. In F. Rauner (Ed.), Handbuch der Berufsbildungsforschung [Handbook of VET research] (pp. 19–27). Wbv.

Marschner, S. (2018). Zur Institutionalisierung der Berufspädagogik: Eine kollektivbiographische Studie zur Disziplinbildung im 20. Jahrhundert [Institutionalisation of vocational education: A collective-biographical study of discipline formation in the 20th century] [Unpublished master thesis]. University of Rostock.

Mehnert, H. (2000). Berufspädagogik in historischer Perspektive [Vocational education in historical perspective]. In G. Pätzold, H. Reinisch, & M. Wahle (Eds.), Profile der Historischen Berufsbildungsforschung [Profiles of research on vocational education history] (pp. 87–100). BIS. http://oops.uni-oldenburg.de/632/79/paepro01.pdf

Moreno Herrera, L., Teräs, M., & Gougoulakis, P. (2019). Emerging issues in research on vocational education & training (Vol. 4). Premis förlag.

Michelsen, S., & Stenström, M.-L. (Eds.). (2018). Vocational education in the Nordic countries: The historical evolution. Routledge.

Ministry of Education, Science and Culture. (2014). The Icelandic national curriculum guide for upper secondary schools: General section. https://www.government.is/library/01-Ministries/Ministry-of-Education/Curriculum/adskr_frsk_ens_2012.pdf

Müllges, U. (1967). Bildung und Berufsbildung: Die theoretische Grundlegung des Berufserziehungsproblems durch Kerschensteiner, Spranger, Fischer und Litt [Bildung and vocational education: The theoretical foundation of the vocational education problem by Kerschensteiner, Spranger, Fischer and Litt]. Henn.

Nilsson, A. (2008). Vocational education and training in Sweden 1850–2008: A brief presentation. Bulletin of Institute of Vocational and Technical Education Nagoya, (5), 78–91.

Nore, H. (2015). Re-contextualizing vocational didactics in Norwegian vocational education and training. International Journal for Research in Vocational Education and Training, 2(3), 182–194. https://doi.org/10.13152

Nyen, T., & Tønder, A. H. (2018). Development of vocational skills through integration of practical training periods in school based vocational education in Norway. In S. Choy, G.-B. Wärvik, & V. Lindberg (Eds.), Integration of vocational education and training experiences (pp. 227–241). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-8857-5_12

Panican, A., & Paul, E. (2019). Svensk gymnasial yrkesutbildning: En framgångsfaktor för en effektiv övergång från skola till arbetsliv eller kejsarens nya kläder? [Swedish upper secondary VET: A success factor for an effective transition from school to work or the emperor’s new clothes?]. Swedish ESF Council.

Pilz, M. (2016). Typologies in comparative vocational education: Existing models and a new approach. Vocations and Learning 9, 295–314. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12186-016-9154-7

Prop. 2009/10:89. Bäst i klassen: En ny lärarutbildning [Best in class: A new teacher training]. Svenska Regeringen. https://data.riksdagen.se/fil/13C34C24-A4DC-4A5A-9CE5-2E0D017F35B7

Pätzold, G. (2011). Akademisierung auf Raten: Der Weg der Gewerbelehrer-ausbildung in die Technische Hochschule [Academisation in rates: The path of industrial teacher training to the technical university]. Zeitschrift für Berufs- und Wirtschaftspädagogik, 107(2), 282–293.

Rapp, A. C., Knutas A., & Smeplass, E. (2023). Bridging gaps in vocational education and training systems in Norway. Journal of Vocational Education & Training, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/13636820.2023.2255992

Rasmussen, P. (2021). Public reason, adult education and social imagination. European Journal for Research on the Education and Learning of Adults, 12(1), 15–29. https://doi.org/10.25656/01:21960

Rauner, F. (2006). Handbuch Berufsbildungsforschung [Handbook of VET research]. wbv.

Reinisch, H. (2011). Geschichte der kaufmännischen Berufe [History of the commercial professions] (Wissenschaftliche Diskussionspapiere 125). BIBB.

Rützel, J., & Schapfel, F. (1994). Professionalisierung von GewerbelehrerInnen: Integrative Studienanteile als Kernstück eines Darmstädter Modells [Professionalisation of VET teachers: Integrative study components as the centrepiece of a Darmstadt model]. In R. Bader, & G. Pätzold (Eds.), Lehrerausbildung im Spannungsfeld zwischen Wissenschaft und Beruf [Teacher training in the field of tension between science and profession] (pp. 345–370). Brockmeyer.

Schapfel. F. (1994). Die Eingliederung der Gewerbelehramtsausbildung in die Technische Hochschule Darmstadt im historischen Kontext [The integration of the VET teacher training programme into the Technische Hochschule Darmstadt in a historical context]. In J. Rützel (Ed.), Gesellschaftlicher Wandel und Gewerbelehrerausbildung [Societal change and VET teacher education] (pp. 19–32). Leuchtturm.

Schmidt, M. G. (2005). Sozialpolitik in Deutschland: Historische Entwicklung und internationaler Vergleich [Social policy in Germany: Historical development and international comparison]. VS.

Schütt-Sayed, S., Vollmer, T., & Casper, M (2021). Förderung nachhaltigkeits-bezogener Kompetenzentwicklung: Praxisheft für die Ausbildung kaufmännischer Berufe [Fostering sustainability-related skills development: Practical booklet for training in commercial professions]. BIBB. https://www.bibb.de/dienst/publikationen/de/download/17097

Skolverket. (2018). Redovisning av uppdrag om statsbidrag för gymnasial lärlingsutbildning 2018 [Report on assignment regarding government grants for upper secondary apprenticeships ]. https://www.skolverket.se/getFile?file=4777

SOU 1994:101. Höj ribban! Lärarkompetens för yrkesutbildning [Raise the bar! Teacher competences for VET]. https://filedn.com/ljdBas5OJsrLJOq6KhtBYC4/forarbeten/sou/1994/sou-1994-101.pdf

Stratmann, K. W. (1994). Die historische Entwicklung der Gewerberlehrer/ innenbildung [The historical development of vocational teacher training]. In J. Rützel (Ed.), Gesellschaftlicher Wandel und Gewerbelehrerausbildung [Societal change and VET teacher education] (pp. 1–18). Leuchtturm-Verlag.

Stratmann, K. W. (1999). Gewerbelehrerbildung zwischen berufsschul-pädagogischen Anforderungen und berufsschulpolitischen Ansprüchen [Trade teacher training between vocational school pedagogical requirements and vocational school policy demands]. In G. Pätzold, & M. Wahle (Eds.), Berufserziehung und sozialer Wandel [VET and societal change] (pp. 477–505). GAFB.

Thomas, W. (1992). Aufgaben und Ausbildung von Diplom-Ingenieurpädagogen in der ehemaligen DDR vor dem Hintergrund neuer Anforderungen [Tasks and training of graduate engineering pedagogues in the former GDR against the background of new requirements]. In K.-H. Sommer (Ed.), Lehrer für berufliche Schulen: Lehrermangel und Lehrerausbildung [VET teachers: Teacher shortage and teacher training] (pp. 331–342). DEUGRO.

UHR. (2024). Fler utbildade yrkeslärare till skolan [More trained vocational teachers for schools]. Universitets- och högskolerådet.

https://www.uhr.se/globalassets/_uhr.se/publikationer/2024/uhr-skrift-2024-06-26-fler-utbildade-yrkeslarare-till-skolan.pdf

Virolainen, M. (2021). Case study Finland (The future of vocational education and training in Europe volume 2. Delivering IVET: Institutional diversification and/or expansion). Cedefop. https://www.cedefop.europa.eu/files/finland_future_of_vet_vol.2.pdf

Virolainen, M., & Stenström, M.-L. (2014). Finnish vocational education and training in comparison: Strengths and weaknesses. International Journal for Research in Vocational Education and Training, 1(2), 81–106. https://doi.org/10.13152/IJRVET.1.2.1

Volanen, M. V. (1999). Bildung through vocational education. In J. Lasonen (Ed.), Workforce preparation in a global context (pp. 167–177). Institute for Educational Research, Jyväskylä. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED438405.pdf

Zabeck, J. (2013). Geschichte der Berufserziehung und ihrer Theorie [History of VET and its theory]. Eusl.

Zimpelmann, E. (2019). Entwicklungslinien des beruflichen Bildungswesens und der Ausbildung von Gewerbelehrern: Eine historische Analyse [Trajectories of the development of VET and the education of VET teachers: A historical analysis. In bwp@ Berufs- und Wirtschaftspädagogik – online, (37), 1–26. http://www.bwpat.de/ausgabe37/zimpelmann_bwpat37.pdf

Øystein, S., & Stråth, B. (1997). The cultural construction of Norden. Universitetsforlaget.